Home
Newsnow

Main Menu
Home
Latest News
The Blog
Squad 2004-2005
Back Issues
Forum
The Web Links
Prediction League
Contact Us
* * * * * * *
Fixtures
Club Honours
Famous Fans
* * * * * * *
The Stats archive
League Apps 1960-
League Goals 1960-
2000s
1990s
1980s
1970s
1960s
1950s
1940s
1930s
1920s
1910s
1900s
1890s
1880s
1870s
Tell yer mates about us
* * * * * * *
Former Hibees
Contributors Login
Username

Password

Remember me
Forgotten your password?
Template Chooser
rhuk_solarflare_ii
Catblog: Answers on a Postcard to the BBC Print E-mail
Written by The Cat   
Monday, 23 February 2004

ImageWhen is a story not a story?

 

Answer: When it's about the Old Firm and broadcast by Scotland’s ”premier” news programmes?

Well, we all remember the non-story that was Marco Negri's squash injury that seem to go on longer than Bryan Adams run at number 1 in the summer of 69, er, I mean, 1991. Tonight's television was no exception with Reporting Scotland giving us the hot-off-the-press report that Shaun Maloney had been stretchered off during an Under-21 game this afternoon against Partick Thistle. Big news indeed.

Had the Bhoy's benchwarmer broken a limb or lost an eye or, heaven forbid, scored a barrelload of goals? No, he'd twisted his knee. Now, I ask you, would it have been a story if it had been Hearts' Robert Sloan or Hibs' Kevin Nicol had suffered the same injury?

Players in similar positions, that of will-only-get-a game-when-others-are-injured, at other SPL clubs wouldn't have been given such airtime so why Maloney? The cynical amongst you must suggest that he only got mentioned because he plays for one of the Old Firm. How could you say such a thing?

Maybe the column inches were merited by a plethora of appearances in the dark blue of Scotland. Er, wrong! So just how did it merit airtime when goals from the weekend's matches were omitted?

I don't suppose that I'm the only person who likes to use Reporting Scotland to catch up with the goals from the weekend. Most people will miss the goals being shown at 5pm on a Saturday as they're still coming back from the games. However, more and more of the weekend action, particularly from non-Old Firm games, is being lost to make way for interviews with O'neill and McLeish or multiples replays of Old Firms efforts.

A recent complaint to the powers that be at Reporting Scotland about the lop-sided reporting of Scottish football met with a predictable response. Apparently, "the purpose of Reporting Scotland is not simply to look back at the weekend's matches or to compare injuries." Fair enough but where's the balance?

You wouldn't get away with this sort of coverage of the 12 main political parties (if there was 12) so why single out 2 teams when the top division consists of 10 other equally newsworthy sides? Answers on a postcard to: Diarmid O'Hara, Editor, Reporting Scotland, Weedja Meedja Land, Glasgow.

Last Updated ( Monday, 23 February 2004 )
< Prev   Next >
Upcoming Games
October
Sat 15th Kilmarnock H
Sat 22nd Aberdeen A
Wed 26th Dunfermline A
Sat 29th Scumski H
Last Five Forum Posts
In the Papers
Copyright 2000 - 2005 Miro International Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.
Mambo is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.